Antiquities dealers are at the centre of the illicit international trade in cultural property writing by archaeologists and art historians brought the issue of antiquities looting to public 1 the term bator, pm (1982) 'an essay on the international trade in art', stanford law review, vol 34, p 275 bator, pm. The illicit trade9 but by only returning a looted object, other parts of the illicit art 5 18 usc §§ 2314-2315 (2012) 6 pm bator, an essay on the international trade in art, “stanford law review” 1982, vol 34, pp 275, 292 7 19 usc §§ 2601- 2613 (2012) 8 al adler, sk urice, resolving the disjunction between cultural. See bator, “an essay on the international trade in art,” 348, 349 (quoting mcclain i, 545 f 2d 988, 1003) 19 see phelan and roussin,“public international law,” 649 (quoting major general conforti, head of the protection of national heritage command of the italian carabineri) lehman, “symposium,” 529 us v. The art newspaper, january 4, 2012 http://wwwtheartnewspapercom/articles/ italy+allows+unesco+into+pompeii/25422 bator, paul m “an essay on the international trade in art” stan l rev 34, no 2 (1982): 275–384 bauer, alexander a, shanel lindsay, and stephen urice “when theory, practice and policy collide. 31 see paul m bator, an essay on the international trade in art, 34 stan l rev 275, 313–14 (1982) see also, eg, united states v mcclain (mcclain i), 545 f2d 988 997 (5th cir 1977) (describing mexico's law on archaeological monuments of 1897, which restricted removal of certain archaeological artifacts from. He also extends the argument of the late paul bator, who in his seminal “an essay on the international trade in art” 34 stanford law review 275 (1982), argued that many restrictions on antiquities, including strong export restrictions serve to increase the black market bennett's piece is a good overview.
Moreover, it is almost unknown, and perhaps conveniently forgotten, that, in his ground-breaking 1973 “essay on the international trade in art”, professor paul bator of the harvard law school concluded that the us should reserve judgment and not simply hand a “blank check” to foreign nations us import restrictions on. Pattern as professor bator explains in his brilliant “essay on the international trade in art,”5 the drafting process was chaotic, and the final text “is not a model of clarity and consistency” in the end, working with mexico and others who understood that the convention could not succeed without us support, we were able to. “report on the situation in africa” unesco doc clt-83/conf216/3 1983 paris: unesco, 1983 google scholar bator, paul m “an essay on the international trade in art” stanford law review 34: 275–384 also published as a monograph the international trade in art chicago: university of chicago press, 1982.
Bator, paul m the international trade in art chicago: university of chicago press , 1983 vii, 108 pp note: this work on the illegal art trade notes in its description of the regulation of the international movement of stolen art treasures and discusses a number of import prohibitions, as well as the responsibility of museums to. Antiquities examined as a criminal market, in art antiquity and law, leicester, institute of art and law, vol 7, n° 1, mars bator, paul m the international trade in art, 2nd ed, chicago, london, university of chicago press, 1996 thinking about the elgin marbles : critical essays on cultural property, art and law, the. Id at 727-28 21 id at 728 (quoting paul m bator, an essay on the international trade in art, 34 stan l rev 275, 372 (1982) [hereinafter bator, an essay)) 22 id at 727 the final vote, taken by hand only (thus erasing any quanti- tative record of which countries voted for or against), was 77 for, 1 against.
Treasures of the american society of international law, and member of the us delegation to the unesco special committee 15 paul m bator, an essay on the international trade in art, 34 stan l rev 275 (1982) in his essay, professor bator observed that most nations rich in archeological sites. Strengthen their arguments the problem is that many of these 14 a colin renfrew, foreword to trade in illicit antiquities: the destruction of the world's archaeological heritage xi, xi (neil brodie et al eds, 2001) 15 see paul bator, an essay on the international trade in art,.
Bailey, m (2007, january) diplomatic licence: an unpublished report claims that antiquities are being smuggled by embassy staff art newspaper, 176 retrieved february 8, 2008, from http://wwwtheartnewspapercom/includes/common/print aspid=552 google scholar bator, p (1982) an essay on the international trade. Smugglers, and the looting of the ancientworld new york: st martin's, 2004 bator, paul “an essay on the international trade in art” stanford law review 34 (1982): 275–384 bichler, gisela, stacy bush, and alili malm bad actors and faulty props: unlocking legal and illicit art trade global crime 14 (2013): 359- 385.